Carlton Fisk 

Taken: Jul 3, 2009

Goose Gossage 

Taken: Jan 28, 2009

Dave Winfield 

Taken: Feb 12, 2009

Jim Rice 

Taken: Jul 3, 2009

Keith Hernandez 

Taken: May 23, 2009

Robin Yount 

Taken: Jul 24, 2008

George Brett 

Taken: Aug 17, 2009

Gary Carter 

Taken: Feb 12, 2009

Willie Randolph 

Taken: May 23, 2009

Ron Guidry 

Taken: Jul 15, 2008

Dennis Eckersley 

Taken: Feb 12, 2009

Bruce Sutter 

Taken: Jul 3, 2009

Mark Fidrych 

Taken: Jul 3, 2009

Andre Dawson 

Taken: Jul 22, 2008

Dale Murphy 

Taken: Jul 22, 2008

Paul Molitor/Alan Trammell 

Taken: Jul 15, 2008

Eddie Murray 

Taken: Jul 22, 2008

Jack Morris 

Taken: Jan 20, 2009